Over the past few years of using datadude (aka DBPro aka Visual Studio Database Projects) I have fallen prey to a peculiar little nuance – if you forget to supply a value for a sqlcmd variable then it will simply use a default and often that is not the desired behaviour. Hence why yesterday I submitted the following suggestion to http://connect.microsoft.com/sqlserver/feedback :
Specify sqlcmdvars properties as "required to be overridden”
In my current place of work I am responsible for maintaining our datadude projects and we have another team that is in charge of deployments. Hence, when we place new properties into the sqlcmdvars file I need to tell the deployment team what values to supply for that property per environment (dev, systest, uat, prod).
Unfortunately lack of communication/human error occasionally creeps in and, for whatever reason, no value gets supplied for some property at deployment time. If this is the case the default value as specified in the sqlcmdvars file gets used instead - invariably this will be the wrong value. I would like a mechanism within SSDT of preventing this from ever happening.
One simple way to prevent this would be to specify that a sqlcmdvars property is *required* to be overridden during the deployment. In other words, never use the default. if an override is not supplied at deployment time then the deployment should fail.
Note that this stipulation should only be in place when deployment occurs from the command-line - if deploying from Visual Studio the default should be allowed (simply because Visual Studio doesn't provide a way to specify anything other than the default value supplied in the sqlcmdvars file).
It transpires that this requested feature is already available in the forthcoming SQL Server Data Tools (SSDT) as I shall now demonstrate. This screenshot shows the project properties of a SSDT project where we define the sqlcmd variables, I have defined a variable called $(Id_value):
In SSDT the nomenclature for deploying a project is “Publish”, a function that can be found by right-clicking on a project in Solution Explorer:
Selecting that brings up the Publish dialog.
Notice how the “Publish” button is greyed out – that it because I have not supplied a value for $(Id_value); supplying a value enables the Publish button and I can go ahead and publish my project. In other words, SSDT insists that I supply a value for that variable – exactly as I requested in my Connect submission.
The same is true if I use the command-line publishing tool sqlpackage.exe. The following command does essentially the same thing as the above depicted Publish dialog:
>sqlpackage.exe /TargetDatabaseName:MyDB /TargetServerName:".\RC0" /Action:Publish /SourceFile:"TestRequiredSqlCmdVars.dacpac"
Executing that gives me an error:
Publishing to database 'MyDB' on server '.\RC0'.
*** Missing values for the following SqlCmd variables:
Here’s a screenshot showing the same:
In order to supply a value for the variable from the command-line you need to use the /v: switch like so:
>sqlpackage.exe /TargetDatabaseName:MyDB /TargetServerName:".\RC0" /Action:Publish /SourceFile:"TestRequiredSqlCmdVars.dacpac" /v:Id_value=1
As you can see, publish was successful!
So there you go, using SSDT you’ll no longer be able to fall prey to the problem I highlighted at the top of this blog post.